Caitie Turner's 'Heartbroken and Milking It' Is For the Hopeless Romantic in All of Us

image

Photo:  Jimmy Fontaine

Catie Turner's music moves through the world with an infectious sincerity, invisible to the passerby but deeply affective to those it happens to grace. It's a testament to her gift for immaculate pop-minded songwriting that carries with it an empathy well beyond her age, and it is a gift she is more than happy to share on her major label debut EP, Heartbroken and Milking It.

Heartbroken and Milking It is a project that stays wholly true its name, casting a light on a Turner in the midst of heartbreak. It tackles its subject matter with a wear your still bleeding heart on your sleeve mentality, managing to uncover the full gambit of human emotions in the process. You'll find Turner delivering a sweeping, lovelorn ballad one moment on "Play God" only to deliver a biting declaration the next on "Therapy." In many ways, it captures the process of heartbreak in its truest form, with no two tracks or moments feeling quite the same.

"When I got my heart broken," Turner shares, "my mom told me to 'not give them any of your energy - they're not worth it!' so I wrote a whole EP about the situation, because I was creative with the ways I ignored my loved ones advice. After lots of crying, trying to manifest a better boyfriend, and a whole lot of mental energy later, Heartbroken and Milking It was born! I hope u enjoy my sad lil baby."

And like any great record surrounding heartbreak, there are traces of the lovesick, doe-eyed optimist. "Love on the Moon" is one particular standout moment that sees Turner opting for a more folk-leaning approach, delivering a minimalistic ballad perfect for the hopeful romanticist. Even for those who feel like they're caught in the midst of love and uncertainty, there's "Push You Away," a driving, anthemic number that shows off the full range of Turner's star potential.

"I don't hate you / I just hate the way I love you," sings Turner in the EP's closing track, "Wish I Didn't Have to (Lie)." It's a succinct yet impactful closing statement that likely hits a little too close to home for anyone who has had their heart broken. But through every moment of Heartbroken and Milking It's emotional journey, Turner remains as a constant point of solace, emerging as an artist more than capable of transforming her own heartbreak into a universally shared moment of empathy.

Listen to Heartbroken and Milking It below:

Related Articles

Tiffany Day’s HALO TOUR Is Everything We Ever Wanted: Concert Review

Tiffany Day’s HALO TOUR Is Everything We Ever Wanted: Concert Review

September 19, 2026 From covering her on our blog in 2020, interviewing her in 2021, and naming her one of OnesToWatch’s “Top 30 Artists to Watch in 2026,” Tiffany Day proved that exactly where she’s meant to be, and that everyone should be watching.
Author: Nicole Oshima
pop
Tender Misfit Will Sell Your Soul (And You'll Thank Her For It)

Tender Misfit Will Sell Your Soul (And You'll Thank Her For It)

September 18, 2026 Wherever Tender Misfit goes next, the next single, the next tour stop, the next sold-out room full of people chanting her lyrics back at her, it's safe to say people will be there for it.
Author: Matt Keenan
pop
Yendry Wants You to Find Yourself in "Como agua" [Q&A]

Yendry Wants You to Find Yourself in "Como agua" [Q&A]

September 18, 2026 Sitting with Yendry in Miami, it's evident how personal this album is to her, and how much she protected it. "I needed to protect it and make sure it was 100% exactly what I wanted to say," she says. "It's my first album. It's scary. It's a leap of faith. I'm proud of myself for trusting my own instinct."
Author: Sarah Ruiz
pop