bby's “2” Is "Slightly Miserable Hopecore" Made Through Jam Sessions and Live Recording [Q&A]

"We never have a setlist" says Benjy Gibson of London-based band bby whilst I watch as he and his fellow bandmates Tommaso Medica, Deon Graham, Jessy Jacquet-Cretides and Tom J Parkin, recount what just happened at their first-ever European headline show. They praise each other whilst discussing the different, unexpected transitions they made, and it amazes me to see how they truly had no idea what song would come next - a true feat of talent and connection. Looking at them does feel like staring at a brotherhood.¨We have to keep our energy precious and strong between us five, because if we are having a good time, everyone else is probably having a good time", says Deon. And after seeing them live in a "hang-like" setting, getting caught in the middle of a mosh-pit and seeing the non-stop energy they bring, I can certainly say that bby knows how to have a good time.
That very high, live energy is at the very core of the band's story, as well as how they make music. Back in London, they are known for hosting "hangs", which are a series of jam sessions held at their space, where people can come and literally hang, listen to the band play what they've been working on and unknowingly give feedback about the music. "Social media encourages such a cult of the individual, and this band is so anti-that…it's about community.., so creating moments where people are just awkwardly bunched together and bumping into each other is so important," says Benjy.
It is at the "hangs" that bits and pieces of their newest album, 2, started to emerge, eventually coming together in a twelve day run at the studio where everything was recorded.
Although sonically a continuation of the exciting, rock sound the band has built up in their previous work, 2 is unafraid to go into a much more vulnerable and experimental territory. Those twelve days at the studio were spent recording each of the songs in one go, with all of the band playing in the same room. “It was a very limiting experience in a good way, " according to Tommaso. With everything being live recorded all the human mistakes, bits and pieces that happened in the room are engrained in the record. Such as in ¨Pull Me Under¨ a song where the voice recording accidentally ended up going through a guitar tremulator and creating a very unique sound.
The album, as many good ones do, traces a breakup. The pushing away, the fighting it, and eventually, the quiet surrender of letting love back in. “It’s the darkest, but also the brightest we’ve ever done,” Tommaso tells me, whilst Benjy and Jessy call it “slightly miserable hopecore.¨ A line of catharsis runs through the project, starting with the album´s opening song ¨Change¨, but I admire the band´s ability to turn quite raw, diary-like thoughts into songs that feel exciting, heady and like proper alt-rock anthems. Songs like ¨Ur Bedroom¨ serve as probably one of the best examples of this sentiment, where cozy, jam session vocals quickly get overtaken by hardcore guitars and drums, courtesy of Tommaso and Tom. If there is one thing that is sure, it is that every song will surprise you and hopefully make you feel like you are in the room with them..
With 2 out in the world, an apparent secret album for the hardcore fans, and some new additions to their yearly-updated album, i just want next year to be better, bby is set for world domination.
OnesToWatch: I wanted to know why you named the group bby. Where did that come from?
Deon Graham: Basically the name kind of came up, but there was already a "baby" or when you search for "baby", an actual child came up (laughs) - so we got rid of the "a". And we think it looks cool. We had a few names before, but bby was just the one where we looked at each other and felt it. It also looks sick on merch [All laugh].
Benjy Gibson: Actually the font of our logo is called "Baby Universe", which is amazing. Tom just randomly found it.
That's meant to be. What would you say your main ethos as a band is?
Deon Graham: I would say listen to each other. Just as a whole, both on and off stage. We've toured for a few years now, so we're quite good at reading how everyone feels off the pitch, so that when we're on the pitch and it's high stakes, we can handle it. I took the lead there, but what do you think boys?
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: I like that!
Deon Graham: We always say it before we go on stage like ¨Listen to each other. This is the thing. This is about us.¨ So we have to keep our energy precious and strong between us five, because if we are having a good time, everyone else is probably having a good time … we hope (laughs).
Benjy Gibson: I would also say high energy is part of our ethos. With our hangs and the shows we started off with are very jammy and messy. And when you are on tour playing bigger shows you can start to get more regimented and strict. We never have a set list, we just freestyle it, jam it and keep it as loose, messy and as live as possible. I think also the new records is that as well, we did many of the recordings in one take.
So even today, you improvised the setlist? Because I didn't perceive that at all or notice you guys choosing which song is next.
Deon Graham: We were literally communicating so much [laughs].
Benjy Gibson: Yeah we did improvise. Someone normally just leads it, they'll start playing some chords and we'll be like ¨okay, that's the next song". It 's very simple.
Tommaso Medica: Today we were playing a new song called ¨Pull Me Under¨ and we made a beautiful jam out of it, so it's a very introspective moment. The fun thing is to break that in the harshest way possible, I think that makes it fun. Especially switching to a higher energy song like ¨Kinky¨ - it's like creating an atmosphere and then destroying it. I love that, it´s the best thing.
Benjy Gibson: He did a wonderful interlude on it all of a sudden (turns to Tommaso), it was like a piece of classical music. Everyone was hypnotized.
I love to hear that you're also surprised by what's going on on stage.
Benjy Gibson: Yeah, because when you're on the road doing shows you can get stagnant and it can get kind of boring. As Deon said, we need to enjoy it so that people can enjoy it. I don't know, sometimes I've seen some bands play 5 years apart and I'm like "bro, that's the same setlist". It becomes like an office job, and that´s exactly what you don't want.
You guys organize "hangs" at your place, so you invite people to party and come watch you jam and play. I'm wondering how these influence the music you make?
Benjy Gibson: Yeah we tried out a lot of stuff during the hangs, so we jammed all of our first record into the making. I think that led to just that relationship of, as we go, to constantly discuss stuff, try it out live and having that very intertwined with our creating process. It also just keeps it fun. Most of the records on the new album are bits and pieces that we´ve been playing around or rambling fake lyrics to for years (laughs), and now we actually finalized them.
You recorded the album fully live, which is a first for you and you did it in a really quick period of time.
Tom J Parkin: 12 days! In the summer.
Wow! How was that? How did it influence the sound?
Deon Graham: We recorded basically two songs a day, but most of them came, as Benjy said, from material we had.
Tom J Parkin: But we did write one fully new song in the studio on the last day pretty much.
Benjy Gibson: The first record was us mostly playing stuff at hangs and me being on my laptop putting in the parts one by one, which just leads to a different process and working (for my Logic producer nerds) with 8 bar loops. Whereas when you have to play the whole song all the way through and it's 4 minutes long, you have mistakes and it slows down and it speeds up, but it also feels deeply human.
Tommaso Medica: It was a very limiting experience in a good way. I think through limitations, you can get great results. Sometimes with a laptop setup, like we made the first album, there's so many options. I think in this case, it's a different kind of restriction, because just the 5 of us in a room, including Benjy singing in the room, was very different from anything we'd ever done before.
You have an EP called i just want next year to be better, so I was wondering what you were up to this year and if it indeed felt a bit better?
Benjy Gibson: Well actually that's a mixtape that we add two songs to at the end of every year. So at the end of 2026 we'll add two songs.
Deon Graham: We always drop the songs during the Christmas - New Year's break,
A little gift. Where did the tradition start?
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: I think nobody really releases songs during that period, so we decided to do it because it's fun.
Tom J Parkin: We had some songs that didn't maybe fit the album as much, but we loved them when we were playing them live so it made sense to release them somehow.
Deon Graham: We actually need to decide which will be the two this year (laughs).
Benjy Gibson: Aside from that, next we've got the last single to come out for the next record, and then the next record itself is dropping November 20. We actually dropped a secret album as well, like 3 weeks ago - the real fans will have hopefully found it.
Okay. I have some detective work to do. Lyrically speaking, who does the most of the writing? Does everyone intervene?
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: Not yet (everyone laughs).
Benjy Gibson: (laughs) It seems Jessy has a plan. But yeah, it's mostly me doing lyrics and melody, and then everything else we do together.
What were you thinking about when writing this record?
Benjy Gibson: The record is generally about a kind of big period of change. I had a break up and it's about that process of fighting that love and pushing it away and then towards the end of the record, it kind of lets it back in and comes home a bit.
You guys wrote the theme song for a really fun show called Adults, so I'm wondering if you guys had your own sitcom show, what would be going on in the episodes?
Deon Graham: We would have a banging sitcom!
Benjy Bibson: It would probably be a kind of anime type thing or kind of like Friends.
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: Friends, but with superpowers [all laugh]
Back to the hangs. I was wondering, when you first started doing them, was it ever intimidating to let people into your space in any way?
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: I think, no because we didn't really have a space before the house [laughs]. I think it was just a little bit of our own cultures because I was a lot into the jam scene in London and we just kind of just brought that into our world right at the start and it was very natural.
Deon Graham: I think that we also grew with the hangs. The first hang that we did, everyone sat on the floor and by the next one, everyone was moving, and then the next one everyone was moshing [laughs]. Maybe if we started in the way that the most recent hang was, it would be a bit more intimidating, but because it was gradual and it started with friends - it felt very easy.
Tom J Parkin: It really did grow with us.
And what does it mean to you guys to create this space for people to share, to dance and be free, especially in the middle of 2026?
Benjy Gibson: I think it's really important. I feel like I could go off on this, but social media encourages such a cult of the individual, and this band is so anti-that. It's a bit clunkier because it's five different people trying to mesh together into a thing, - and it's inherently harder to maneuver, but it's about community and that manifests in the show as well. I think when people watch us, there's this feeling of seeing us being a community and then wanting to be a community as well with us. People are increasingly isolated, so creating moments where people are just awkwardly bunched together and bumping into each other is so important.
When people listen to this album, what are you hoping they'll feel from it?
Tom J Parkin: Well, I hope it can bring them back to the hangs. I hope that they can feel like they are in the room with us five together.
Deon Graham: I think it feels quite optimistic. It's a journey, a really honest, human one and it´s very vulnerable in terms of sound and lyrics - with the main message being that everything will be alright.
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: It may be a longshot, but it feels like Hopecore.
Benjy Gibson: Yeah, a slightly more miserable hopecore (all laugh), but there's still hope.
Tommaso Medica: It's the darkest, but also the brightest that we've ever done, there's extremes in this album - both sound and theme wise.
Yeah, I think in general, very different from what bands nowadays do in our generation. You said this was your first ever headline show in Europe, right? So how does it feel to maybe be conquering some new continents?
Tom J Parkin: Like Napoleon (laughs).
Deon Graham: Yeah, it feels good. European shows are so much nicer. The musical scene and care that goes into artists, the UK could learn from that a bit. I love London, but hospitality in Europe is better.
Are there any emerging artists that you guys are really into right now and would recommend people to listen to? Do you listen to very different kinds of music?
Jessy Jacquet-Cretides: I would say so, yeah. But they kind of cross over a little like a Venn diagram. My artist would be Anatole Muster, it's hopecore-like jazz and he plays the accordion too!
Benjy Gibson: Mine is called Rian Brazil. I love him.
Tommaso Medica: Mei Simones is incredible. It's complicated guitar playing, but it's direct and beautiful, and it's mixed with indie pop.
Tom J Parkin: Mine is 1earphoneeach, they have a cool indie vibe.
Deon Graham: Brian Nasty and Issadora who are opening up for us on tour are amazing. And if not them, then an artist called Mudi Sama.
Thank you so much guys and congrats on an amazing album.
bby: Thanks so much.
Listen to 2 below: