Knox is the Boy from New Carlisle, OH [Q&A]

Photo by Lily Nelson
When this writer first met rising pop-punk singer-songwriter Knox in the summer of 2023, the rising star was a somewhat fresh-faced Atlantic Records signee less than a month away from releasing what would become his signature hit, “Not The 1975.” Following the success of that tune, and several others, we have gone onto chat in support of all three of his subsequent projects dating back to 2023’s I’m So Good Alone At Being Alone?, with his latest, My Midwest Best, out now.
Knox, who playfully admitted, “I just woke up about 15 minutes ago and got out of the shower four minutes ago,” upon jumping on our Zoom chat from his tour bus ahead of his recent Sacramento, CA show, is on tour once again. It’s his sixth overall in three years, this time in support of MWB, along with opening act guitar goddess Emi Grace, who Knox calls “another level of talent.”
His sold-out show at NYC’s Brooklyn Bowl this past October saw he and his band, made up of trusted bandmates and confidants Cam Becker, Christian Delzoppo, and Johnny Townsend run through 24 songs in just under 90 minutes. The setlist features 10 out of 12 MMB tunes, callbacks to Going Going Gone, I’m So Good…, and How to Lose a Girl In 7 Songs, as well as brand-appropriate snippet covers of songs by 5SOS and WALK THE MOON. It is a show dedicated to fan service, an assumption proven further with group viewings of livestreamed sports in venue parking lots and friendly pre-show competition. “We've been playing Mario Kart at VIP,” Knox said with a smile. “And if anybody beats me, they can have whatever they want from the merch table. So far, nobody's beat me. I feel bad.”
As much of Knox’s music is largely fictitious, elements of his day-to-day life seldom make their way forward. MMB, which sees him explore and delve into the sound and cultural aspects of his early years growing up in New Carlisle, OH, is his most pertinent and direct example of this, with songs like “4:3 Forty, “What Do I Know,” and “Sad Song” exploring both the primitive and the personal. “Have you ever been to Skyline Chili?,” he asked with as deadpan an expression as he wore amid a snafu with his in-ear monitor in Brooklyn, when asked for anecdotal references to his hometown. “It’ll change your life, bro.”
Led by pre-release singles “After The After Party,” “Long Story Short,” “Better Than Me,” and “Go For Broke,” the latter pair serving as an aggressively pushed social media darling and the current tour equivalent to the room-shaking “Pick Your Poison” off GGG respectively, Knox established early dominance on MMB. Album tracks like “Mixed Feelings,” “Ready Or Not,” and “Gone Missing” have begun to sprout as live exposure provides new context for fans, though the impossibly difficult “I Think You Should Leave,” a tune Knox himself feels may be the toughest of his catalog due to its vast melodic trajectory, has not yet found its way on to the internet.
On closing track “Sad Song,” Knox provides a peek into his world as intimately as he does on the undeservingly overlooked GGG track “Win Some, Lose Somebody.” In the first verse, he sings, “No, I’ve never been cool/ I’ve never been tough/ Just another weirdo singin’ ‘bout love,” a genuinely affecting admission applicable to any creative with growing pains. “Someone’s always out there screamin,’ ‘Give it up, give it up!’/ But maybe I won’t if they’re gonna show up/ Maybe I don’t really wanna grow up/ But, maybe I’m happy singin’ sad, sad songs.”
OnesToWatch: “Go For Broke” is becoming the “Pick Your Poison” of this album. Having experienced other songs of yours gain traction like that, what's the band response when you guys see that that's what's going on from the stage?
Knox: Dude, I think the response is like “One of 'em's working, let's keep pushing it and keep playing that one and posting videos of it.” I like that you say it’s like “Pick Your Poison,” 'cause it really was. It was the first song we put out this year, it's doing great. It was really big in Japan for a minute, which was sick. And seeing the crowd response, that's definitely the most fun new song to play. I love just saying the first two words and then the crowd just sings the rest of it.
It’s also happening for “Ready or Not,” which is one of the NEW new ones. How does that feel for that song to be out for less than a month and to have that kind of response?
It's awesome, especially “Ready or Not,” because that was a song that was almost one of the singles, that I still think maybe probably should have been. It’s the oldest song on the album, and was made before everything else. it's nice to see a song that you've always believed in get that kind of validating response.
Which one are you hoping gets that kind of buzz later on?
I mean, not to sound greedy or anything, but I'll take any of ‘em! If I had to choose one out of the songs that came out on album day, it would be “Ready or Not.” Maybe shockingly, I thought “Gone Missing” was gonna be one that people really, really loved. I think people like it, but I thought that was gonna be one of the ones, and I don't think it is yet.
I thought “I Think You Should Leave” would have that that same thing too…
I haven't even posted that song on the internet yet. I need to show the world that it exists. And it's not on the set list because we sing so many songs, and that's the hardest song to sing in my catalog. And also, full transparency, that and “Vultures” were the two songs off the album that I thought, “I think we’ll be okay if we didn't play this live.” Last year I kind of had this with “Voicemail.” I didn't know that was gonna be a song people loved, so I left it off of the set list and then for the rest of the year it was like, “Why did you not play ‘Voicemail’??” So, I was very deliberate with which songs we didn't play from the album. And “Vultures,” I think we're good on because the set is so upbeat and fun and no one wants to hear about me being sad on “Vultures.” That one was okay. but I've gotten a little bit of pushback on “I Think You Should Leave,” so maybe maybe we'll add it eventually.
You play 24 songs in an hour and 25 minutes. Does it feel like whiplash for you guys being up there?
It did during rehearsals, and it did maybe for show one in Boston. But, once you get it down, especially for me personally, since I'm not a trained singer, learning the songs is always kind of a process. It's one thing when you record a song, because when you sing a song in the studio, you sing every single line a hundred times and pick all the best ones and stream it all together. It takes me a minute to because I recorded these songs back in March, and then you don't sing them again until you get on tour. You have to pick and choose where your breathing spots are and how to make the songs easy.
I would say probably after Brooklyn was when I got really comfortable with the set. Now, we get on stage and it feels like 15 minutes and the set's over. It's like, “Dang, dude, I wish we played more songs!”
We've talked about a lot of your songs not necessarily equating to your real life, but “Sad Song” and “What Do I Know” feel very close to it. Agree or disagree?
Totally agree. There are songs on the album that I made to be the kind of Knox songs that are just FUN. But there are a couple songs, like “Vultures,” “What Do I Know,” “Sad Song,” and “Ready or Not” that were all journal entries. Like, pure diary thoughts to music, which I feel like I've not done a ton of in my artist career, coming from someone who has the songwriter background first. I've always just written songs. On a couple of these songs, I tried be fully vulnerable. Just letting people in on the mind of me, I guess.
Do you actually have a journal? Do you write in it every day?
If my notes apps counts as that! I don't write things in a journal, but I'm constantly putting stuff in my notes, all music related, but also just thoughts, because you never know. I had a song on my last album called “Win Some Lose Somebody.” That was one that sat in my notes for almost a year, and then I found it randomly one day and was like, “Dude, that's kind of a cool thought.”
The first verse of “Sad Song” made me cry in a Bushwick Starbucks the first time I heard it…
[Laughs] Haha, very nice.
… “I've never been cool, never been tough, just in a weirdo singing about love.” Was that a sentiment that you had been sitting on for a while?
Man, I wanted a song like this on the album really bad. I have a girlfriend. I've been in a relationship for four and a half years. I'm gonna get engaged soon. Things are things are like, REALLY good for me, you know? I, as a tortured songwriter, or whatever, I'm not real tortured right now. I’ll come home from the studio with, for example, “I Think You should Leave,” and I'm like, “Alicea, you gotta hear this song!” And then I play it, and she's like, “Dude, that's great. But like, should I go?” And I'm like, “NO NO NO, this isn't about us!” She would always like make fun of me for it.
So, I wanted to have a song that was kind of about that. I always tell her, like, yes, things are always good, but these are the kind of songs that make me feel connected to my audience, and music in general. When I was growing up, the songs that I was always attracted to were the heartbreak songs. They make you like feel something, you know? So yeah, that song is just about that, no matter how good things are, I'm always gonna write these songs. I'm always gonna want to sing about stuff like this.
What midwesternisms do you think you carry with you presently?
Dude, I don't even know how to put it into words. This is gonna sound really dumb, but there's this thing about people from Ohio that when you meet somebody, I swear to goodness, you know if they're from Ohio. All my band guys… we all met completely randomly in Nashville, but they’re all from Ohio. I feel like I grew up in the middle of nowhere. I graduated with 44 kids in my high school class, and we were a public school. People from where I'm from don't do the thing that I do. And I've just been considered very, very lucky. I don't know exactly what the characteristics are, but I just know that whether I'm playing a sold-out show in New York, or I'm on a Zoom call with you doing an interview, I'm still that same person who is from the middle of nowhere who feels a little imposter syndromey every now and again. And I love Skyline Chili, man. That's it, THAT’s pretty Ohio of me.
You love a what???
Have you ever heard of Skyline Chili?
No!!
I'm gonna put you on. Skyline Chili, man. Change your life.
Is that a chain or…
It's a restaurant in Ohio. It's the best food you could ever eat, man. I promise.
Is that the Ohio equivalent of a Wawa?
Yeah, you could say that. It's a little more niche. It's a weighted debate because you either love Skyline, or it's the nastiest thing you've ever eaten.
What's a niche spot someone should visit if they’re driving through New Carlisle?
Ooooooh. There's one local restaurant in my town called Studebakers. On snow days when we would get snowed out at school, my dad would take me and my brother up to Studebakers, and we'd get the trucker special. That's the spot. Right there, right on Main Street, New Carlisle. The place to be.
What is your current favorite album by a Midwest artist?
I just gotta be honest, KINDA HARD by Bilmuri, dude. That's what I'm listening to.
I don't know the girl's name in his band, but, when I saw them in Brooklyn last summer, she hit a note that was so high I was literally stomping around the balcony in shock.
Yeah, dude, she's gotten so good at singing. It's always really cool because they play both of my songs that I have with them on their set list and she sings my part and I love seeing the videos because she's so good. I'm like, “Damn, bro, you're kind of singing it better than I than I even would. So don't get too much better!”
Is there going to be a deluxe of this album, or are you content with keeping it at the standard?
Yeah, we'll see! I really want to take my time and really let this album sit with people. I posted at the end of last year around Christmas time that I was officially burned, and I still kind of am. I put out “Sneakers” and then I've just not stopped putting out music since then. Like even since Going, Going, Gone. We've not stopped putting out music, and we're already two albums in, you know? So, I was gonna take a break last year, but things with “Go For Broke” happened and it was like, “Let's just make another one.” And coming from someone that goes to the studio every day when I wake up, even when I'm taking a break, I'm still gonna go to the studio. I'm still gonna be making music, just maybe off of socials. The next time I put out music, whether it's a deluxe or whatever that looks like, when that comes out, I will be a legitimate break. I'm out for a little bit.
I was so shocked when “White Knuckles” came out because I was like, “Where was this on the original GGG???”
Yeah! I think that's the point of a deluxe. To be like, “Okay, what's the album? What's it missing? If you were listening to it one more time and going back, what do you think it could have?” That's what's fun about a deluxe. You can kinda experiment with new sounds and new vibes that probably weren't explored on the actual record.
The social content for some of these, especially “Better Than Me,” has been extensive. One, do you ever feel self-conscious doing the public ones? And two, what's a concept you haven't explored yet?
Well, in public, this is gonna sound really dumb, but I mean this genuinely. It is so easy. I'll do them in public all day. Like, hey, if I'm doing “Not The 1975” in public, no problem. Because if somebody's like, “Look at this clown,” I can be like, “It's got five hundred thousand views!! What are you talking about?” When a song isn't working and it doesn't have that many views, then I'm a little more like, “My God, okay, let's just like rip this real quick.” Thankfully, “Better Than Me” was doing great and still is doing great. So yeah, I don't really care when I'm in public. I'd rather be doing that than teaching kindergarten kids, you know?
I would say the one thing I haven't explored, content wise… I don't even know if I have what it takes to be honest. You ever seen Cam Whitcomb? He'll do funny skits. He did one with Marshmallow recently that was really funny. Maybe I could do that, but I don't know if I have the acting chops. I don't know if I'm funny enough.
Listen to 'My Midwest Best' below: